Wigs and Words of Wisdom: The Honor Council Hosts a Mock Hearing

Ginna Allen

News Editor

In early November, the Honor Council donned their gowns and powdered wigs to host a mock hearing and share more about their work as a council. As attendees gathered in Convocation Hall and enjoyed Chick-fil-A, council members shared the event’s goal: to showcase their internal procedures for honor code violations. 

“I wanted there to be an understanding of what we actually do on council. I want honor to be part of the conversation on Sewanee’s campus,” said Honor Council president Ella Madej (C ‘26) when reflecting on this goal. “We talk about EQB a lot and what that means and what it means to be a Sewanee student or what it means to live in a community here. But I started thinking more about what honor means outside of academics, and I think that we’ve created a culture of honor at Sewanee. So I’d love to lean into that more rather than focus on the ways that we bring down the hammer.”

With this idea of honor in mind, the mock trial followed a particular case in which a student was accused of using outside sources and plagiarism on a final exam. As Madej explained the case, folders with the case materials were handed out to the crowd, which included the essay from the accused student, the class syllabus and email exchanges between the student and the professor. The case itself was real, but the names and identifying features in the case material had been changed for privacy purposes. In the trial, the council members acted as they would in a real case, with the role of the student being taken on by Sara Beth Smotherman (C ‘26) and Alexander Bruce, faculty advisor for the Honor Council, acting as the professor.

Moving through the case, the nine sitting council members explained the different phases of review, discussion and voting with a required two thirds majority to reach a ruling. The process is rooted in a face-to-face format, as shown in the extensive discussion and reenactments of conversations with the student and the professor in the case. This also included a part of the trial where the student can express their side of the case to the council, and  the professor can explain their reasoning for the accusation, to which the council can then ask questions. The audience was also invited to offer their own questions to the student, professor, and council members in regard to the case. Involving the audience then allowed the event to delve into interesting conversations about the case itself in tandem with the general processes of the Honor Council. 

Sophomore representative Winnie Alford (C ‘29) told the Purple that events like the mock hearing gives the Honor Council a chance to show the behind-the-scenes to students and faculty. “We know that the Honor Council plays sort of a shadowy role on campus, which can create a sense of fear and mistrust around the council and the work we do,” said Alford. “We put on the hearing with the hope that students would get a better understanding of what it is we look at when hearing cases, as well as get a sense of the decision-making that determines adequate consequences. We don’t want students to fear us or be scared that we’re ‘out to get them,’ we just want everyone to know that we’re there if we are needed, and that what we do has strict rules and formulas to produce the best results.”   

Looking ahead, the Honor Council seeks to keep up their collaboration with the community in an effort to make the council into a more outward-facing body. This goal works alongside their hopes to continue supporting campus initiatives, student organizations, and academics. Alford said the Honor Council is partnering with psychology professor Dr. Yu’s senior seminar, which looks into judgment and decision-making. “Her students were present at the mock hearing and are using some of what they learned to generate ideas about how to make the honor council better in deliberations, campus presence, and many more areas of improvement. The mock hearing was a great first step in that direction, as well as being a great launching point for more events focusing on transparency in the future,” Alford said.  

Leave a Reply