Broderick and DesJarlais: Your Vote Matters

Harper Rzepczynski

Opinions Editor

Last week, stars and stripes gleamed as the American people took their chance to cast their ballots, upholding our beloved foundation of democracy. Though the race deciding who will serve Sewanee in Congress has not been officially called by the Associated Press, with >95% of votes counted as of Nov. 13, sources such as NBC News, Nashville Banner, and Tennessee Lookout have declared Rep. Victoria Broderick the winner of Tennessee’s fourth district, which includes Murfreesboro, part of Nashville, and our very own Mountain. Broderick narrowly beat the incumbent, Scott DesJarlais, by only 280 votes, giving Tennessee a taste of the blue wave. Furthermore, one thing is clear: your vote matters.

Broderick, a working-class Democrat mother residing in rural Tennessee, centers her platform around affordable homeownership and childcare, expanding Medicaid in the state, protection of gun-owners while investing in community violence prevention and background checks, ending federal penalties for marijuana possession, raising corporate tax, and legalizing abortion, as stated on Victoria4Tennessee. She also opposes current immigration enforcement and the US-Israel-Iran war. Her triumph is especially impressive considering she only raised about $100,000, only a sixth as much money as her opponent. On her website, she states, “I’ve never been the type to wait around when something needs fixing. I get to work. I’m ready to bring that same energy to Washington and make sure our communities have a voice at the table.”

In contrast, DesJarlais, who held his seat for eight terms, has long touted his Tea Party and family values beliefs. He proposes tax reductions, a decrease in “costly government regulations,” rejection of the Affordable Care Act, prioritization of the military, support for farmers, and complete protection of the 2nd Amendment, displayed on DesJarlais’ website. He has also consistently voted against abortion and medical protections for those who receive treatment and openly supports ICE under Trump. Additionally, DesJarlais voiced his support for the war with Iran in an interview where he stated that he favors “national security” despite the majority of Republicans moving away from supporting the wildly unpopular conflict that only 31% of Americans support.   

On the surface, DesJarlais checks most conservative boxes, and it’s no surprise that a historically red stronghold such as Tennessee voted for him time and time again. However, upon deeper inspection, I discovered that DesJarlais has quite a rough personal history. To start, it is public record that, during his divorce proceedings in 2001, his wife had two abortions, which he says were a “mutual decision” due to “therapeutic reasons” the first time and because “things were not going well” the second time. In addition, when he was a doctor before entering politics, he was found responsible and fined by the Tennessee Board of Medical Examiners for having sex with his patients. Even worse, he also pressured one of the patients he was engaging with sexually to have an abortion. When asked, he stated that he merely wanted her to admit that she was not pregnant even after she testified under oath that she had indeed been impregnated by him. I would like to emphasize that DesJarlais voted against abortion and Planned Parenthood four times in 2025 alone. His hypocrisy speaks for itself. 

DesJarlais’ other personal actions are problematic as well. According to Politico, his divorce file details him dry-firing an unloaded gun at a bedroom door while his first wife ran inside as well as holding a pistol in his mouth for about three hours. It is also mentioned that he prescribed medication to a patient while he was dating her. It is important to note that, even after this information was released to the public, he continued to hold his seat in Congress for several more terms. After all of this, all DesJarlais has to say for himself is “I know God has forgiven me.” Even if he is being genuine, I, as a Christian, would prefer to leave religious justification for wrongdoings out of politics. 

It is also important to note that the 2026 midterms saw a historic voter turnout. To be more specific, 123.5 million Americans voted, which is 49.1% of all eligible voters, making 2026 the second highest turnout since 1914, with the 2018 midterms still in the lead with 50.3%. Though a historically high number of people voted this time, half of those able to vote still did not. According to data from the Census Bureau, 20% of people who did not vote in 2024 simply lacked interest, 18% were too busy, 15% did not like the candidates, 12% struggled to get to the polls due to illness or disability, 7% were outside of their hometown/district, and 4% just forgot. These reasons likely still stand true in this past election.

Even Sewanee itself saw a large uptick in voter turnout. The congressional race reported 936 votes, with 77.14% supporting Broderick, with 48.75% of eligible voters in Sewanee’s precinct participating in this past election. Comparing this to only 117 voters in 2022’s congressional race demonstrates a remarkable change.

I say all of this to perpetuate one particular idea: every single vote matters, yours included. Your vote in your state matters, your vote in your district matters, and your vote in your town matters. This congressional race, decided by a mere 280 votes, proves that your vote matters. The fact that Tennessee’s fourth district could have kept a faithless, morally corrupt representative in Congress if 300 supporters of Broderick had decided not to cast their ballots makes it a definite truth that your vote matters. If you are unsatisfied with the results of elections, vote next time. If you are completely happy with who won, vote next time. If you want something fixed, vote in favor of it. If you want something to stop, vote against it. My conclusion stands as this: voting is our point of power, our opportunity to bring change, and, most importantly, our responsibility to ourselves and the rest of the American people. Your vote matters.

Leave a Reply