Carl’s Legacy

Irene Boehm

Sports Editor

“When you love them so big, it hurts so big” – Former Sewanee Equestrian Director, Karine Gordy

In early October, the Mountain lost a special soul, and an angel gained his wings.

Carlson, or “Carl,”, a veteran member of the Sewanee Equestrian herd, was found in the field exhibiting signs of distress. Barn staff immediately tended to him and assessed his condition. We called the vet, and after a professional evaluation, he concluded that the beloved horse no longer had control of his back legs. This was likely from an acute injury that couldn’t be seen — a devastating but common occurrence in older horses.

In collaboration with the vet, it was decided the best thing for Carlson was to lay him to rest. Our coaches Taylor Herzog and Lizzie Chamberlin (C ‘23) took him to the University of Tennessee to have a necropsy done to receive a full report of why his health shifted so suddenly.

I was in class when I received the email from my coaches. When I read “Carlson” in the subject line, I held my breath for several seconds before opening it. I knew in my bones what was coming, but as I read the news, shock still washed over me. I immediately thought of my teammates and all the times we shared with Carl. 

Days before the incident, I was finishing up at the barn with some teammates when the question was proposed: “”Who would be the ‘mascot horse’ of our team?” “Carl, of course,” one of my teammates said. “Yeah, duh, Snarl is the OG,” another one echoed. Snarl was one of several nicknames Carl had  collected over the years. Like a close friend, we gave Carl nicknames. We knew him inside and out, saw him as a soul member of the team, and apparently now the “mascot horse.” Carl was a core member of our herd from my first day on the team. He was the first horse I rode at Sewanee and remains one of the most special horses in my heart.

A special memory with Carl was beating No. 1-ranked Lynchburg my freshman year in 2024, the biggest win in program history. I had the honor of riding Carl in that meet. When we heard the final score confirming our win, we all jumped and hugged each other in the indoor area. After the awards ceremony, we ran back to the stables and gave our horses love and probably a few too many treats. We all ran to Carl’s stall, where he waited eagerly for his well-earned handful of treats and favorite neck scratches.

The week after his passing, we beat No. 2 Lynchburg and Sweet Briar. I know Carl was watching over us that weekend. After the awards ceremony following the historic win, we cried, laughed and hugged, just like in that first-year win over Lynchburg. As usual, we all ran to the barn to give our horses love. It was difficult to come back to see that Carl’s stall was empty this time. But we all came together in agreement that Carl was there in spirit, cheering us on and celebrating with us from above.

From the day he passed to the difficult days that followed, our coaches were incredibly supportive. From that first email to follow-up texts, they emphasized the importance of looking out for each other and taking the time we needed before returning to our busy lives as student-athletes.

Coach Chamberlin knew Carl longer than any of us; she was on the team when he was first donated. Coach Herzog had known Carl for only a handful of months, but as she said at his honor ceremony, that was all she needed to know how special he was and the huge role he played for the program. “He was so dependable for me in my transition here… He was always so consistent; I knew I could count on him,” she shared.

His absence is felt in the barn, across the Domain and even in alumni nationwide who mourned his loss.On Instagram, team members, alumni and even students outside the team shared hundreds of photos and words honoring the love and joy Carl brought to their time on the Mountain: a testament to how many lives he touched. 

A few weeks after his passing, the team traveled to Charleston for a meet. Upon arriving, a mother, father and their young daughter approached our visiting team tent. The parents were alumni and had visited Sewanee weeks earlier, spending lots of time at the barn with their daughter, who clung to a horse stuffed animal as she ran over to say hello. I know I wasn’t the only one who saw myself in this young, horse-crazy girl. She couldn’t have been older than six, but she already dreamed of joining the Sewanee Equestrian team one day. 

Several of us gathered around her as she talked about her visit to the barn. Then, out of nowhere, her eyes lit up. She ran over to her mom, shouting, “Mommy, show them my horsey.” Her mom came over and said that during their Sewanee visit, they had met a special horse  “the friendliest gentle giant” who let the daughter give him treats and even kisses. 

The Mom flipped her phone toward us, and my teammates and I immediately looked up at each other, knowing exactly who we were about to see. The Mom flipped her phone toward us, and there was Carl, his head gently tilting down to meet this little girl as she leaned in and kissed his nose. 

This is the legacy of Carlson. It is manifested in the ongoing impact he has on our team and people across the country. He lives on in the memories of everyone lucky enough to be touched by his sweet, one-of-a-kind soul. If you visit the barn, you will see a stall lit with candles, floral arrangements and goofy photos that show his peaceful yet silly, playful personality. Seeing his stall almost every day reminds me to cherish the ones I love, whether it’s a horse or a human; you never know when you may lose one you love so deeply.

Leave a Reply